In this article, we discussed international treaties, the types, the opportunity created by treaties, the challenges and the future.
Definition
International treaties are formal, legally binding agreements determined in written form between two or more states or international organizations and governed by international law, establishing rights and obligations for the parties involved. They are a significant source of international law and can be referred to by various names like conventions, protocols, pacts, or agreements, depending on their specific content rather than their designation.
Features of International Treaties:
Binding Agreements:
Treaties create legally binding obligations for the states or organizations that are party to them.
Written Form:
They are always concluded in written form, even if they are part of a single instrument or multiple related instruments.
Governed by International Law:
International treaties are subject to and governed by the rules and principles of international law.
Purpose:
They are used to regulate interactions and transactions between states, address issues like peace, defense, human rights, trade, and establish international institutions or mechanisms for enforcement.
Examples of Names:
While the term “treaty” is common, they can also be called conventions, protocols, covenants, charters, pacts, agreements, or memorandums of understanding (MOUs), among others.
Bilateral and Multilateral:
Treaties can be bilateral (between two parties) or multilateral (involving several parties).
Types of International Treaties Affecting Oil Exploration
1.1 Maritime Boundary Treaties
Maritime boundary treaties define the limits of national jurisdiction over ocean resources. These treaties are essential for offshore oil and gas exploration.
UNCLOS (United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea):
UNCLOS is the foundational treaty that establishes the legal framework for maritime zones:
Territorial Sea (up to 12 nautical miles)
Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) (up to 200 nautical miles)
Continental Shelf (which can extend beyond 200 nautical miles if geologically justified)
Under UNCLOS, a coastal state has sovereign rights to explore and exploit natural resources in its EEZ and continental shelf. Disputes often arise when multiple states claim overlapping zones, affecting licensing and development of offshore oil fields.
Bilateral and Multilateral Boundary Agreements
Countries enter bilateral or multilateral treaties to resolve overlapping maritime claims and create joint development zones (JDZs):
Timor Sea Treaty (2002) between Australia and East Timor allowed joint oil exploration in contested waters.
Environmental Treaties
Oil exploration has significant environmental implications. Treaties at the international level aim to mitigate environmental risks:
Paris Agreement (2015): While not directly about oil, this climate treaty influences national energy policies and investment in oil exploration through commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD): Can affect oil exploration in sensitive ecological zones, particularly offshore and Arctic areas.
These treaties often require environmental impact assessments (EIAs), stricter emissions controls, and may limit exploration in protected zones.
Investment Protection and Trade Treaties
Oil exploration is capital-intensive and carries high risk. Treaties that protect foreign investors are crucial in encouraging exploration in developing or politically unstable regions.
Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs): Offer protections such as non-discrimination, fair treatment, and protection from expropriation.
Arms Control and Sanctions Treaties
Certain treaties or international sanctions limit oil exploration by restricting access to resources or technology:
UN Security Council Resolutions can prohibit oil exploration in conflict zones (e.g., Libya, Iran, North Korea).
These treaties and sanctions can effectively isolate countries from international collaboration and investment.
Mechanisms of Influence
Legal Clarity and Sovereignty
Treaties help define sovereign rights over oil-rich territories, especially offshore. This clarity is essential for issuing licenses and attracting exploration investment.
Access to Resources
Only states recognized as having jurisdiction over a given territory or maritime zone can legally grant exploration rights. Disputed zones without treaty resolution (e.g., South China Sea) are high-risk and generally avoided by major oil companies.
Investment and Risk Management
Treaties reduce legal and political uncertainties, making oil exploration more attractive to multinational companies. Treaty-backed arbitration mechanisms offer a path for legal redress, improving investor confidence.
Regulation and Environmental Standards
Environmental treaties impose operational standards and can prohibit or delay projects that do not meet compliance criteria. This raises the cost but also reduces the ecological risk of oil operations.
Conflict Prevention and Joint Development
Treaties create frameworks for cooperation in disputed or shared areas. Instead of conflict, countries may agree to jointly explore and profit from hydrocarbon resources.
Opportunities Created by Treaties
Investor Confidence: Legal protection from treaties attracts foreign direct investment (FDI) and reduces political risk.
Dispute Resolution: International arbitration under treaties provides neutral venues for resolving disputes.
Joint Ventures: Treaties encourage bilateral cooperation in joint development areas, spreading exploration costs and profits.
Environmental Governance: Ensures responsible exploration that aligns with global sustainability goals.
Challenges and Limitations
Non-Compliance and Power Politics: Some powerful states may ignore rulings (e.g., China in the South China Sea), undermining treaty effectiveness.
Ambiguity in Treaties: Terms like “fair and equitable treatment” can be interpreted broadly, leading to legal uncertainty.
Slow Treaty Negotiations: Treaty-making and boundary demarcations can take decades, delaying exploration.
Sanctions Volatility: Changing political climates can suddenly alter the viability of projects through new sanctions or treaty withdrawals (e.g., U.S. leaving the Iran nuclear deal).
Environmental Restrictions: Treaty-imposed environmental obligations can restrict or delay high-impact projects.
Influences of International Treaties on Future Oil Exploration:
Environmental Protection and Sustainability:
International conventions, such as the International Convention on Civil Liability for Oil Pollution Damage and regulations on marine pollution, will continue to drive stricter environmental standards in oil exploration and production, requiring companies to mitigate pollution and invest in cleaner technologies. Advocates of a “fossil fuel non-proliferation treaty” also propose restrictions on expanding new fossil fuel frontiers and promoting a “managed decline” of existing infrastructure, directly impacting future exploration activities.
Contractual Frameworks and Investment:
Treaties and evolving international law will continue to shape the contractual landscape between host states and international oil companies (IOCs), particularly production sharing agreements (PSAs), influencing cost recovery, risk sharing, and profit distribution. International arbitration mechanisms, as established by treaties like the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties and the ICSID Convention, will provide frameworks for resolving disputes, though consent is required for jurisdiction.
Geopolitical Shifts and Energy Transition:
The rise of renewables and the global push to limit carbon emissions will alter the geopolitical landscape of oil, potentially leading to decreased demand and a shift in investment away from fossil fuels, with implications for exploration in existing and new frontiers.
Landlocked Countries’ Access to Resources:
International agreements like the New York Convention on Transit Trade of Landlocked States and the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) will continue to ensure transit rights for landlocked countries involved in oil and gas exploration and transportation, including the use of pipelines.
Conclusion
International treaties are fundamental to the governance of oil exploration. They create the legal frameworks that define rights to explore, provide protections for investors, and ensure environmental safeguards. While they can open up new areas for development and reduce the risk of conflict, they also introduce complexity and constraints.
READ: How AI is Improving Exploration Accuracy